We don't score or rank sunscreens. We read every label the FDA has on file, the printed Drug Facts and the filing behind it, and show what we find as facts, each with its official source. What to avoid is your call. The rules are the same for every brand, including ours.
Sunnytime is checked the same way. I make a mineral sunscreen. When ours is on the FDA registry it goes through these exact rules, and what they find about it shows up like everyone else's, including the synthetic polymer powders it uses for texture.
How a result is laid out
At a glance. The same checks on every product, in the same order, so two sunscreens can be compared side by side: FDA recall, Broad Spectrum, the UV filters (mineral or chemical), spray or powder, an age limit or adult skincare active, fragrance, and a possible SPF booster listed as an inactive ingredient.
About the UV filters. Each chemical filter on the label, with its official limits in the US and the EU, and where state or county law bans its sale.
Label check. What the label itself shows: a UV filter listed as an inactive, a fragrance-free claim next to a fragrance, an ingredient banned in EU cosmetics.
Check for your child. Ingredients that matter mainly for some children. Tap Eczema, Psoriasis, Food allergy or Under 3 and the ones that apply are highlighted, with the guidance written for that situation.
Other ingredients some parents ask about. Ingredients parents often ask about, with the official findings we found for each. Listed because parents ask, not because a rule flags them.
What the colours mean:
Green: the check found nothing of that kind on the label.
Amber: pediatric or dermatology guidance (AAP, AAD) applies, the product is above an EU limit, an EU rule restricts the ingredient for young children, or the item matches what you told us about your child.
Blue: a fact to know: where a law bans its sale, how a rule elsewhere treats it, a study finding, or something the label leaves unclear.
Red: an FDA recall, an FDA order or warning that removes the ingredient or product type, or a combination pediatricians advise against.
Products are never ranked by how many items they have. Under every item, "Why this matters" lists the facts behind it, one sentence per source, then what points the other way and what no source has settled.
Every fact, with its source
These are the same sentences the result card shows. A law is called a law, a proposal a proposal, a recommendation a recommendation, and a single study a study.
At a glance
FDA recall
FDA Class I: “a reasonable probability” that using the product “will cause serious adverse health consequences or death.” FDA · checked 2026-10-26agency guidance
FDA Class II: the product “may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences,” or serious harm is remote. FDA · checked 2026-10-26agency guidance
FDA Class III: using the product “is not likely to cause adverse health consequences.” FDA · checked 2026-10-26agency guidance
Each FDA recall record names the firm that recalled and which products, sizes, lots or stores it covers. FDA · checked weeklyfederal database
Not known
A recall on record does not mean the bottle you have was affected: check the lot, size or store in the record.
Benzene recalls
Aerosol spray sunscreens are among the products FDA lists as recalled for benzene contamination. FDA · current as of 2025-03-12agency guidance
Broad Spectrum and SPF
Under FDA labeling rules, “Broad Spectrum” means the product passed a test for UVA protection in addition to UVB. FDA · 2011 rulefederal regulation
Sunscreens that are not Broad Spectrum, or are below SPF 15, must carry the warning: “This product has been shown only to help prevent sunburn, not skin cancer or early skin aging.” FDA · updated 2026-10-16agency guidance
FDA: choose a broad-spectrum sunscreen with an SPF of at least 15. FDA · updated 2026-10-16agency guidance
The CDC: SPF 15 or higher, broad spectrum, every 2 hours. CDC · undatedagency guidance
FDA has proposed (not finalized) that the maximum labeled SPF be 60+. FDA · 2021-09-24proposed order (not final)
Mineral or chemical UV filters
The AAP's environmental health page says: “Mineral-based sunscreen (e.g., zinc oxide) is preferable to chemical-based sunscreen (e.g., oxybenzone).” American Academy of Pediatrics · updated 2024-01-10medical society guidance
The AAP's 2021 safety tips say: “If possible, choose a sunscreen with the mineral ingredients zinc oxide or titanium dioxide.” American Academy of Pediatrics · 2021-06-07medical society guidance
In 2021 FDA proposed (still not final) that zinc oxide and titanium dioxide are generally recognized as safe and effective at up to 25%. FDA · 2021-09-24proposed order (not final)
For 12 older chemical filters, FDA proposed in 2021 that more safety data are needed; FDA says this is not a conclusion that they are unsafe. FDA · current as of 2026-09-10agency guidance
In an FDA study in healthy adults who applied sunscreen to most of the body, six chemical filters (avobenzone, oxybenzone, octocrylene, homosalate, octisalate, octinoxate) reached blood levels above the point at which FDA asks for further safety studies, after one application. The authors said this does not mean people should stop using sunscreen. JAMA (study by FDA scientists) · 2020-01-21peer-reviewed study (adults)
FDA lists aerosol sunscreens among products recalled for benzene contamination; FDA says benzene is not usually used to make drugs, so it appears as a contaminant. FDA · current as of 2025-03-12agency guidance
In the EU, nano zinc oxide may not be used in applications that could expose the user's lungs by inhalation. European Union · 2016-04-21EU law
FDA's 2021 proposal would keep sprays as an allowed sunscreen form, subject to testing and labeling requirements. FDA · 2021-09-24proposed order (not final)
Age limits
US sunscreen labeling rules require the directions to say “children under 6 months of age: Ask a doctor.” FDA · 2011 rulefederal regulation
FDA: “Sunscreen is not recommended for infants under six months old.” FDA · updated 2026-10-16agency guidance
FDA's infant page adds that “the best sun protection for these infants is to stay in the shade.” FDA · current as of 2026-09-10agency guidance
Health Canada says sunscreen and insect repellent can be used safely together as separate products: apply the sunscreen first, then the repellent. Health Canada · 2018-06-01agency guidance
PABA or trolamine salicylate
FDA issued a final order in September 2026 that sunscreens with PABA or trolamine salicylate as actives are not generally recognized as safe and effective; it takes effect in September 2027. FDA · issued 2026-09-11, effective 2027-09-11final order
Hydroquinone
FDA: “there are no FDA-approved or otherwise legally marketed OTC skin lightening products.” FDA · 2022-04-19agency notice
FDA says over-the-counter hydroquinone products are deemed new drugs and are misbranded, and had to come off the market by September 23, 2020 unless FDA approved them. FDA · 2022-04-19agency notice
FDA has received reports of serious side effects, including skin rashes, facial swelling and ochronosis, a skin discoloration that may be permanent. FDA · 2022-04-19agency notice
The EU limits oxybenzone to 6% in face, hand and lip products (not sprays) and 2.2% in body products, including sprays. European Union · 2022-07-07EU law
Hawaii has banned the sale of sunscreens containing oxybenzone (or octinoxate) without a prescription since January 1, 2021, citing harm to coral reefs. State of Hawaii · 2018-07-03, sale ban from 2021-01-01state law
Homosalate reached blood levels above FDA's further-testing threshold in an FDA study in healthy adults. JAMA (study by FDA scientists) · 2020-01-21peer-reviewed study (adults)
What points the other way
FDA says its 2021 proposal that more data are needed for homosalate and other filters “does not represent a conclusion by the FDA” that they are unsafe. FDA · current as of 2026-09-10agency guidance
In a 2025 safety review, Australia's TGA recommended limiting benzophenone in sunscreens to 383 ppm; this is a recommendation, not yet a final rule. Australia TGA · 2025-07agency review
Hawaii bans the sale of sunscreens containing oxybenzone or octinoxate without a prescription (Act 104, from January 1, 2021), citing harm to coral reefs. State of Hawaii · 2018-07-03, sale ban from 2021-01-01state law
Sale banned on Maui
Maui County bans the sale, distribution and use of non-mineral sunscreens without a prescription, from October 1, 2022. Maui County · effective 2022-10-01county law
A limit in one country does not by itself show harm in another: each regulator sets limits on its own safety review.
SPF above 50
The AAP recommends SPF at least 15 “(up to SPF 50)” and says more research is needed to test whether SPF above 50 offers extra protection. American Academy of Pediatrics · updated 2024-08-09medical society guidance
FDA has proposed (not finalized) that the maximum labeled SPF be 60+. FDA · 2021-09-24proposed order (not final)
DailyMed, the National Library of Medicine's database of FDA label filings, keeps a new version each time a label's filing changes. US National Library of Medicine · checked weeklyfederal database
Not known
This can be a correction to the filing, not a new formula.
A change in the filing does not show when the product on the shelf changed; older stock may still be sold, so check the tube.
Same ingredient list as other labels
These labels list the same active ingredients at the same strengths and the same inactive ingredients in the same order in their FDA filings. US National Library of Medicine · checked weeklyfederal database
Not known
A matching list does not show who makes the product, or that the amounts of each inactive ingredient are the same.
A general FDA rule requires inactive ingredients in over-the-counter drugs to be safe in the amounts used and not to interfere with the product's effectiveness; it does not address SPF boosters specifically. FDA · currentfederal regulation
This product lists the ingredient named on the card among its inactive ingredients.
Its status as a UV filter in the US, the EU and Australia is shown on the card. European Union · 2026-05-18EU law
Butyloctyl and tridecyl salicylate are salicylates, the same chemical group as the approved filters octisalate and homosalate; the Cosmetic Ingredient Review assessed them together with octisalate (ethylhexyl salicylate). Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel · 2003industry-funded expert safety panel
What points the other way
A 2003 Cosmetic Ingredient Review assessment that covered butyloctyl and tridecyl salicylate found these ingredients safe in cosmetics when formulated to avoid skin irritation and increased sun sensitivity (or with directions for daily sun protection). Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel · 2003industry-funded expert safety panel
In 2025 the panel re-reviewed salicylic acid and 17 salicylates and found them safe as currently used in cosmetics when formulated to be non-irritating and non-sensitizing. Expert Panel for Cosmetic Ingredient Safety (CIR) · 2025industry-funded expert safety panel
We found no published study measuring whether butyloctyl salicylate or tridecyl salicylate is absorbed into the body.
How much of this product's SPF, if any, comes from these ingredients cannot be told from the label.
We found no FDA rule, guidance or warning letter about SPF boosters.
4-methylbenzylidene camphor
The EU banned 4-methylbenzylidene camphor in cosmetics: none could be newly sold from May 1, 2025 and none at all from May 1, 2026. European Union · 2024-04-03EU law
The EU scientific committee found sufficient evidence that it may act as an endocrine disruptor, and could not set a safe concentration because data on possible genotoxicity were insufficient. EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety · 2022EU scientific opinion
What points the other way
Australia's 2023 sunscreen guidelines permitted it up to 4%. Australia TGA · 2023-05agency guideline
Australia's TGA published a new safety review of it in September 2026. Australia TGA · 2026-09agency review
FDA says there are no federal standards for the term “hypoallergenic”; it means whatever a company wants it to mean. FDA · accessed 2026-10agency guidance
Check for your child
Fragrance
US rules let companies list all fragrance components as one word, “Fragrance”. FDA · current as of 2022-02-28agency guidance
FDA says some fragrance components may cause allergic reactions or sensitivities. FDA · current as of 2022-02-28agency guidance
The EU requires named fragrance allergens to be listed individually above 0.001% in leave-on products. European Union · 2023-07-26EU law
The 2022 US law MoCRA required FDA to propose a similar fragrance allergen labeling rule by June 29, 2024. FDA (Unified Agenda) · Fall 2024 agendafederal regulatory agenda
Trade press reported that FDA's July 2026 regulatory agenda projected that proposal for November 2026; it had not been published as of that report. ChemLinked (trade press) · 2026-07trade press report
FDA says diethyl phthalate (DEP) appears to be the only phthalate still commonly used in cosmetics, and it may be part of an ingredient listed as “fragrance”. FDA · current as of 2022-05-19agency guidance
What points the other way
FDA says it does not have evidence that phthalates as used in cosmetics pose a safety risk. FDA · current as of 2022-05-19agency guidance
Lavender or tea tree oil
A 2007 report described three healthy boys whose breast growth started while using products containing lavender oil (in one case also tea tree oil) and stopped when the products were stopped. New England Journal of Medicine · 2007-02-01case reports + lab study
NIEHS researchers found chemicals in these oils with estrogen-like or anti-androgen activity in cell tests; an NIEHS scientist described such effects in children as very rare. NIEHS (NIH) · 2019-09government research news
What points the other way
A 2021 survey study of more than 550 children reported no link between lavender or tea tree oil use and hormone effects; it came from a research center that works with natural-products brands. Franklin Health Research Center (study in Int J Pediatr Adolesc Med) · 2021-11-17press release on a survey study (industry-linked center)
Not known
Case reports cannot show the oils caused it, and we found no established safe or unsafe amount.
MI or MCI preservative
The EU has banned methylisothiazolinone in leave-on cosmetics since February 12, 2017, because no safe level for causing skin allergy was shown. European Union · 2016-07-22, applies 2017-02-12EU law
The EU requires products to be labeled “releases formaldehyde” when released formaldehyde exceeds 0.001%. European Union · 2022-07-08EU law
Propyl- or butylparaben
The EU bans propylparaben and butylparaben in leave-on products designed for the diaper area of children under 3, because a risk for babies under 6 months could not be excluded. European Union · 2014-09-18EU law
What points the other way
Outside diaper-area products for young children, EU law allows propyl- and butylparaben up to 0.14% combined, a limit set on the EU scientific committee's safety advice. European Union · 2014-09-18EU law
FDA: “At this time, we do not have information showing that parabens as they are used in cosmetics have an effect on human health.” FDA · current as of 2025-11-18agency guidance
Retinyl palmitate (vitamin A)
In a 2012 government study, a cream with retinyl palmitate sped up skin tumors caused by simulated sunlight in hairless mice. US National Toxicology Program · 2012-08government research (mice)
EU law adopted in 2024 caps vitamin A at 0.05% (retinol equivalent) in body lotion and 0.3% in other products, and requires the label “Contains Vitamin A. Consider your daily intake before use.” European Union · 2024-04-03EU law
What points the other way
The EU scientific committee found vitamin A safe in cosmetics at those limits, while noting that food and supplements alone may push the most-exposed 5% of people above the upper limit. EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety · 2022-10EU scientific opinion
Not known
The study was in mice and did not draw conclusions about people; we found no FDA statement on retinyl palmitate in sunscreen.
Food-derived ingredients
NIH peanut allergy guidelines identify infants with severe eczema, egg allergy, or both as at highest risk of peanut allergy, and advise that, after evaluation, peanut-containing foods be introduced as early as 4 to 6 months. NIH / NIAID · 2017-01government clinical guideline
A 2003 UK observational study found peanut-oil creams used on babies' rashes were associated with a higher risk of peanut allergy; the researchers said this needed confirmation and that parents should ask a doctor before changing creams. University of Bristol (ALSPAC study in NEJM) · 2003-03-11university release on an observational study
What points the other way
FDA’s over-the-counter monograph lists colloidal oatmeal as a skin protectant active ingredient. FDA · 2021-09-24federal monograph
The skin-exposure link comes from observational studies and is a hypothesis, not a proven cause. Refined oils may contain little protein; labels do not say.
Citrus peel oil
Furocoumarins, found naturally in some citrus oils such as bergamot and lime, can cause a skin reaction when the skin is then exposed to UVA light. Cutis (Janusz, Schwartz) · 2021peer-reviewed review
EU law requires furocoumarins to stay below 1 mg/kg in sun protection and bronzing products. European Union · consolidatedEU law
Not known
The label does not say whether this oil has had its furocoumarins removed.
Lanolin
The American Contact Dermatitis Society named lanolin its 2023 Allergen of the Year; a review published with the designation lists children and people with eczema among higher-risk groups. Cutis review (Johnson, Norman, Adler, Yu) · 2023peer-reviewed review
Among children referred for patch testing in a US registry, those with eczema reacted to cocamidopropyl betaine more often than those without eczema. Pediatric Contact Dermatitis Registry (Jacob et al.) · 2017peer-reviewed study (referred patients)
What points the other way
The Cosmetic Ingredient Review panel concluded in 2010 that it is safe in cosmetics when formulated to be non-sensitizing, and has linked sensitization concerns to manufacturing impurities (amidoamine and DMAPA). Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel (Burnett et al.) · 2019industry-funded expert safety panel
Propylene glycol
The American Contact Dermatitis Society named propylene glycol its 2018 Allergen of the Year; a systematic review calls it a weak sensitizer and an irritant. McGowan, Scheman, Jacob · 2018peer-reviewed review
What points the other way
Among 6,761 people with suspected contact dermatitis patch tested in Australia (2005-2020), 21 (0.31%) reacted to propylene glycol, and 9 of them had a reaction judged relevant. Patel, Palmer, Nixon, Contact Dermatitis · 2023peer-reviewed study (referred patients)
Eczema and psoriasis
For a child with eczema
The AAD: “To prevent a flare due to sunscreen, use sunscreen that contains only these active ingredients: titanium dioxide, and/or zinc oxide.” American Academy of Dermatology · accessed 2026-10medical society guidance
The National Eczema Association's Seal considers only physical sunscreens containing titanium, zinc and iron, and requires products to be fragrance-free. National Eczema Association · modified 2026-08-25patient-organization certification criteria
What points the other way
An AAP page on eczema and sports recommends a broad-spectrum, oil-free, water-resistant sunscreen of at least SPF 15, without specifying mineral filters. American Academy of Pediatrics · accessed 2026-10medical society guidance
DermNet NZ notes that many allergies to sunscreen products are caused by inactive ingredients, such as fragrances or preservatives, rather than the UV filter. DermNet (New Zealand) · 2012, updated 2024medical reference (dated)
On the National Eczema Association's exclusion list
A product cannot carry the National Eczema Association's Seal if it contains any ingredient on its exclusion list, in any amount. National Eczema Association · modified 2026-08-25patient-organization certification criteria
This product contains the ingredient named on the card.
A 2023 review in the journal Dermatitis names oxybenzone as the most frequently reported contact and photocontact allergen among UV filters. Ekstein and Hylwa, Dermatitis · 2023peer-reviewed review
The same review found no reports of allergic or photoallergic contact dermatitis to zinc oxide or titanium dioxide. Ekstein and Hylwa, Dermatitis · 2023peer-reviewed review
An AAP page on eczema in teens lists alcohols such as ethanol among ingredients that may irritate the skin, and adds that each person may react differently or not at all. American Academy of Pediatrics · accessed 2026-10medical society guidance
The AAD says skin injuries, including sunburn, can trigger a psoriasis flare near or at the injury, about 10 to 14 days later. American Academy of Dermatology · accessed 2026-10medical society guidance
EU law does not allow salicylic acid in preparations for children under 3 (the only exception is shampoos, where it is used as a preservative). European Union · 2019-11-27EU law
Common allergens in children
Among 1,871 children referred for patch testing in North America (2001-2018), the most common relevant allergens were nickel (17.3%), hydroperoxides of linalool (7.8%), methylisothiazolinone (7.7%), cobalt (7.0%) and fragrance mix I (4.9%). North American Contact Dermatitis Group (Silverberg et al.) · 2022peer-reviewed study (referred patients)
Not known
These figures come from children already referred for testing, so they are not population rates.
In 2019 France required most leave-on products with phenoxyethanol to carry a label against use on the diaper area of children aged 3 and under; its highest administrative court annulled that decision in 2022 for lack of legal basis. France Conseil d'État (copy published by FEBEA) · 2022-12-29court decision
PEG and other ethoxylated ingredients
FDA says these ingredients can carry trace 1,4-dioxane, a manufacturing byproduct it calls a potential human carcinogen. FDA · current as of 2022-03-03agency guidance
New York limits 1,4-dioxane to 10 ppm in cosmetics and 1 ppm in personal care products; the state's guidance does not say whether over-the-counter sunscreens are covered. New York State DEC · accessed 2026-10state law
What points the other way
FDA reports the EU committee considered trace levels of 10 ppm or less safe, and that levels have fallen over time. FDA · current as of 2022-03-03agency guidance
Not known
A label cannot show whether any 1,4-dioxane is present.
BHA
The US National Toxicology Program lists BHA as reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen, based on animal studies; it says human data are inadequate. US National Toxicology Program · 15th edition (2021)government research
California lists BHA under Proposition 65 as a chemical known to cause cancer (since 1990). California OEHHA · listed 1990-01-01state law listing
The EU scientific committee found BHT safe up to 0.8% in leave-on and rinse-off cosmetics (lower in mouthwash and toothpaste), a limit it set after considering concerns about BHT’s potential endocrine-disrupting properties. EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety · 2021-12-02EU scientific opinion
Talc
FDA says talc can be contaminated with asbestos, a known cause of cancer when inhaled. FDA · current as of 2026-01-16agency guidance
FDA proposed asbestos testing of talc cosmetics in 2024 and withdrew the proposal in November 2025, saying it will issue a new one. FDA (Federal Register) · 2025-11-28federal notice
WHO's cancer agency classified talc as probably carcinogenic (Group 2A) in 2024, citing limited evidence in humans for ovarian cancer (from studies of genital use), sufficient evidence in animals and strong mechanistic evidence; it said asbestos contamination could not be ruled out in the human studies. This rates hazard, not the risk from a given product. IARC (WHO) · 2024-07-05WHO agency classification
What points the other way
Health Canada concluded most uses of talc are not a concern to human health; its concerns were breathing in loose powders and genital use. Health Canada · 2021-04-22agency assessment
Petrolatum or mineral oil
Germany's BfR found no health risk to be expected from highly refined (pharmaceutical-grade) mineral oils applied to the skin. Germany BfR · 2018-02-27national agency assessment
US labels do not say whether the mineral oil or petrolatum is highly refined.
Nano zinc oxide or titanium dioxide
In its 2019 sunscreen proposal, FDA wrote that zinc oxide stays mainly in the outer dead layers of the skin, whatever its particle size. FDA · 2019-02-26proposed rule (superseded proposal)
The EU allows nano zinc oxide up to 25%, under conditions on purity and coating, but not in products that could expose the lungs by inhalation. European Union · 2016-04-21EU law
The EU allows nano titanium dioxide up to 25% under similar conditions, also not in products that could expose the lungs by inhalation. European Union · 2016-07-13EU law
California lists titanium dioxide under Proposition 65 only in the form of airborne, unbound particles of respirable size. California OEHHA · listed 2011-09-02state law listing
Australia's TGA concluded these nanoparticles are not likely to cause harm in sunscreens. Australia TGA · 2016-08agency review
Not known
US labels are not required to say whether zinc oxide or titanium dioxide is nano-sized.
Other checks we run
Less common findings, each with the rule or reference it rests on. Where a flag is our own judgment rather than an official rule, it says so.
Chemical UV filter listed among inactive ingredients
We flag this because a chemical UV filter appears among the inactive ingredients instead of being declared as a sunscreen active. It may be there as a stabilizer or at a level that adds no SPF; the label does not say which.
Source: OTC Monograph M020 / 21 CFR 201.327: sunscreen actives must be declared in Drug Facts. Reading an inactive-listed filter as undeclared is TinySafe label analysis.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains methyldibromo glutaronitrile, banned in EU cosmetics
A preservative that causes skin allergy; the EU decided in 2003 to remove it from leave-on products and in 2007 banned it from all cosmetics, with sales ending by June 2008. The US FDA has not banned it.
Source: Commission Directive 2003/83/EC (24 Sept 2003): leave-on prohibition (text not read - date per EUR-Lex metadata and Br J Dermatol 2004;151(4):817). Commission Directive 2007/17/EC (22 March 2007): prohibited from all cosmetics (deleted from Annex VI, ref. 36; not placed on the market from 23 March 2008, not sold after 23 June 2008). Today not an authorised preservative under Annex V of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009.Contains IPBC
The EU does not allow it in any product for children under three except bath products, shower gels and shampoos. It is also not allowed in body lotions or body creams for any age.
Source: Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Annex V entry 56 (iodopropynyl butylcarbamate): max 0.02% rinse-off, 0.01% leave-on, 0.0075% deodorants; not in products for children under 3 except bath products/shower gels and shampoos; not in body lotion or body cream; not in oral or lip products.Contains an adult skincare active
We flag exfoliants, brighteners and self-tanners because we do not think they belong in baby sunscreen; that is our judgment, not a rule. The EU sets concentration limits for arbutin and the self-tanner DHA, not age limits.
Source: EU Annex III: arbutin (max 7% face cream) and alpha-arbutin (max 2% face cream, 0.5% body lotion) - Commission Regulation (EU) 2024/996; dihydroxyacetone (max 10% self-tanning) - Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1099. US: DHA is a color additive, 21 CFR 73.2150. Classification: TinySafe judgment.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains D4 (cyclotetrasiloxane)
The EU classifies D4 as toxic to reproduction and prohibits it in cosmetics. California's AB 496 adds it to the state cosmetics ban from Jan 1, 2027; the bill does not say whether that covers sunscreens sold as OTC drugs.
Source: EU Cosmetics Regulation Annex II entry 1388 (octamethylcyclotetrasiloxane, CAS 556-67-2), added by Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/831 - prohibited in cosmetics. REACH Annex XVII (Commission Regulation (EU) 2024/1328): D4 max 0.1% in wash-off and leave-on cosmetics. California AB 496 (2023): cyclotetrasiloxane added to the Toxic-Free Cosmetics Act ban, effective Jan 1, 2027.Contains talc in a spray or powder
We flag talc in sprays and powders, where it can be breathed in, because of concern about asbestos contamination in talc; giving it extra weight there is our judgment. FDA proposed asbestos testing for talc cosmetics in Dec 2024 but withdrew it in Nov 2025, so no testing rule is in force.
Source: FDA proposed rule 'Testing Methods for Detecting and Identifying Asbestos in Talc-Containing Cosmetic Products', 89 FR 105490 (Dec 27, 2024), Docket FDA-2023-N-4225 - WITHDRAWN Nov 28, 2025; FDA says it will re-propose under MoCRA sec. 3505.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains triclosan or triclocarban
Antimicrobials the FDA ruled in 2016 were not shown to be safe and effective in consumer antiseptic washes, because makers did not supply enough data. That rule covers rinse-off washes, not leave-on products.
Source: FDA final rule, Safety and Effectiveness of Consumer Antiseptics; Topical Antimicrobial Drug Products for OTC Human Use, 81 FR 61106 (Sept 6, 2016): 19 actives including triclosan and triclocarban not GRASE for consumer antiseptic washes. EU: triclosan/triclocarban restrictions updated by Regulation (EU) 2024/996.Contains formaldehyde
A known contact allergen and carcinogen.
Source: Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/831 (22 May 2019): formaldehyde, paraformaldehyde and methylene glycol added to Annex II and deleted from Annex V entry 5. ACDS Allergen of the Year 2015: Ponten A, Bruze M. Formaldehyde. Dermatitis. 2015;26(1):3-6. doi:10.1097/DER.0000000000000075. Carcinogen: IARC Group 1.Water-based with no listed preservative
We flag this because water-based products need some way to stop microbes growing, and no preservative is listed. Some products protect themselves in other ways, such as low water content or airless packaging, which the label may not show.
Source: 21 CFR 211.113(a) (written procedures to prevent objectionable microorganisms in non-sterile drug products); ISO 11930 and ISO 29621 (preservative efficacy / low-risk products); FDA BAM Chapter 23 (cosmetic microbiology methods). None requires a listed preservative. Flag: TinySafe judgment.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains a phthalate
The EU bans specific phthalates in cosmetics, such as dibutyl phthalate, diisobutyl phthalate and DEHP. Not every phthalate is banned; diethyl phthalate (DEP), common in fragrance, is not.
Source: EU Cosmetics Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 Annex II: dibutyl phthalate (entry 675), diisobutyl phthalate (entry 1492, added by Regulation (EU) 2019/831); DEHP also prohibited. Diethyl phthalate not prohibited.Contains an ingredient the EU restricts for children under 3
The EU does not allow salicylic acid in products for children under three (the 2019 rule text exempts shampoos). Boric acid is now banned in EU cosmetics for all ages, and California bans boric acid and borates from Jan 1, 2027.
Source: Salicylic acid: Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 Annex III entry 98 (amended by Regulation (EU) 2019/1966 and 2021/850) - not for preparations for children under 3 (2019/1966 text: 'except for shampoos'; survival of exception after 2021/850 not confirmed). Boric acid: prohibited, Annex II entry 1395 (2020); borate salts not individually verified. California AB 496: boric acid/borates banned from Jan 1, 2027.Contains a PFAS ingredient (fully fluorinated)
Since 2025 several US states ban intentionally added PFAS in cosmetics. Whether those laws reach sunscreens, which the FDA regulates as drugs, differs by state.
Source: State laws banning intentionally added PFAS in cosmetics: California AB 2771, Colorado HB 22-1345, Maryland, Minnesota HF 2310 (Amara's Law), Washington HB 1047 (RCW 70A.560) - effective Jan 1, 2025 (Washington's 'intentionally added' rule from 2027); Maine (38 M.R.S. sec. 1614) and Vermont S.25 - Jan 1, 2026; Connecticut 2028. Coverage of OTC-drug sunscreens not confirmed for any state.Contains a plant from the ragweed (Asteraceae) family
The daisy family (Compositae, also called Asteraceae) is a well-known group of plant allergens. Arnica is a stronger sensitizer than German chamomile.
Source: Wallace CE, Elston DM. Asteraceae Dermatitis: Everyday Plants With Allergenic Potential. Cutis. 2024;114(4):E18-E21. Paulsen E. Contact sensitization from Compositae-containing herbal remedies and cosmetics. Contact Dermatitis. 2002.Contains bee-derived ingredients
This flag is driven by propolis, a documented contact allergen: in one patch-test study, about 1 to 6% of dermatitis patients reacted to it. Other bee ingredients such as beeswax and honey are included but are not the reason for the flag.
Source: Nyman GSA, Gimenez-Arnau AM, Grigaitiene J, Malinauskiene L, Paulsen E, Hagvall L. Patch Testing with Propolis of Different Geographical Origins in a Baseline Series. Acta Derm Venereol. 101(11):adv00591. doi:10.2340/actadv.v101.423 (1.3-5.8% positive in 1,470 dermatitis patients).Contains an alkyl glucoside (such as decyl glucoside)
A plant-derived emulsifier. The American Contact Dermatitis Society named alkyl glucosides Allergen of the Year in 2017.
Source: ACDS Allergen of the Year 2017: Alfalah M, Loranger C, Sasseville D. Alkyl Glucosides. Dermatitis. 2017;28(1):3-4. doi:10.1097/DER.0000000000000234; Loranger C, Alfalah M, Ferrier Le Bouedec MC, Sasseville D. Alkyl Glucosides in Contact Dermatitis: A Systematic Review. Dermatitis. 2017;28(1):5-13. doi:10.1097/DER.0000000000000240.Contains a sulfite
Used to keep ingredients from oxidizing. The American Contact Dermatitis Society named sulfites Allergen of the Year in 2024.
Source: ACDS Allergen of the Year 2024: Ekstein SF, Warshaw EM. Sulfites: Allergen of the Year 2024. Dermatitis. 2024;35(1):6-12. doi:10.1089/derm.2023.0154.Contains isobornyl acrylate
An acrylate the American Contact Dermatitis Society named Allergen of the Year in 2020, mainly because of reactions to glucose sensors and insulin pumps. It is rare in sunscreens.
Source: ACDS Allergen of the Year 2020: Aerts O, Herman A, Mowitz M, Bruze M, Goossens A. Isobornyl Acrylate. Dermatitis. 2020;31(1):4-12. doi:10.1097/DER.0000000000000549.Contains natural rubber latex
Natural rubber latex proteins can cause allergic reactions. FDA's latex labelling rule applies to medical devices, not sunscreens; we cite it only as evidence of the allergy.
Source: 21 CFR 801.437 (user labeling for medical devices containing natural rubber, 62 FR 51029, Sept 30, 1997) - a device rule, cited only as evidence that NRL proteins cause allergic reactions.Preserved with methyl- or ethylparaben
The EU's scientific committee (SCCS) considers methyl- and ethylparaben safe at permitted levels; listed because parents ask.
Source: SCCS/1652/23, Opinion on methylparaben (adopted 14 Dec 2023, corrigendum 28 Feb 2024): safe as a preservative up to 0.4% alone (0.8% total esters). Ethylparaben: SCCS 2011 parabens opinion - methyl- and ethylparaben safe at maximum authorised concentrations.Contains an ethanolamine (TEA/DEA/MEA)
Can form nitrosamines with certain preservatives.
Source: Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 Annex III entries 60 (fatty acid dialkanolamides), 61 (monoalkanolamines) and 62 (trialkanolamines): not to be used with nitrosating systems; max secondary amine content; max nitrosamine 50 ug/kg; nitrite-free containers. (Free DEA's own EU status not confirmed.)Contains silicones (non-cyclic)
Silicones are used for texture and spread; we list them for information, not as a safety flag.
Source: TinySafe informational flag. No specific CIR report cited or verified.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Tinted with iron oxides
Mineral pigments; listed because tint changes how it looks on skin.
Source: 21 CFR 73.2250 (iron oxides, color additive for cosmetics, exempt from certification); 21 CFR 73.1200 (synthetic iron oxide, drugs).This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains a synthetic dye
Added for colour only; we list synthetic dyes for information.
Source: 21 CFR Parts 74 and 82 (certified color additives). Informational flag: TinySafe judgment.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains SLS or SLES
Cleansing surfactants that can irritate skin, more so at higher concentrations.
Source: CIR. Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Sodium Laureth Sulfate and Ammonium Laureth Sulfate. J Am Coll Toxicol. 1983;2(5):1-34. doi:10.3109/10915818309140713.Preserved with sodium benzoate or benzoic acid
Can cause non-allergic redness (contact urticaria) in sensitive skin.
Source: CIR. Final report on the safety assessment of Benzyl Alcohol, Benzoic Acid, and Sodium Benzoate. Int J Toxicol. 2001.Contains plant extracts
We count plant extracts by botanical name as our own measure. A 2020 expert panel advised that baby skincare be free of sensitizing agents, but it did not single out plants.
Source: Schachner LA, et al. J Drugs Dermatol. 2020;19(8):769-776. doi:10.36849/JDD.2020.5252 ('sensitizing agent-free'; does not rank plants). Counting method: TinySafe label analysis.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains a synthetic polymer powder (for texture)
A synthetic polymer powder added for texture and finish. The label names the ingredient; it does not show particle size or form.
Source: EU CosIng ingredient function entries. Context: EU REACH restriction on synthetic polymer microparticles, Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/2055.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains animal-derived ingredients
For families avoiding animal products.
Source: Label reading (TinySafe).This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains shea butter
Refined shea carries almost no allergenic protein; listed for families who avoid it.
Source: Chawla KK, Bencharitiwong R, Ayuso R, Grishina G, Nowak-Wegrzyn A. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2011;127(3):680-682 (shea nut butter has no detectable IgE-binding soluble proteins). FDA 'Questions and Answers Regarding Food Allergens' Edition 5 (Jan 2025) removed shea nut from the FALCPA tree-nut list.Contains coconut-derived ingredients
FDA no longer counts coconut as a tree nut for food allergen labelling. We list it for families who avoid it.
Source: FDA 'Questions and Answers Regarding Food Allergens' Edition 5 (Jan 6, 2025): coconut is no longer a FALCPA 'tree nut'. Preference flag: TinySafe judgment.This flag is our own judgment, not an official rule.Contains cyclic silicones D5/D6
The EU limits D5 and D6 to 0.1% in leave-on cosmetics from 6 June 2027, because of environmental persistence, not skin safety.
Source: Commission Regulation (EU) 2024/1328 (16 May 2024) amending REACH Annex XVII: D5 and D6 max 0.1% in leave-on (and D6 in wash-off) cosmetics from 6 June 2027; D4/D5 already restricted in wash-off under Regulation (EU) 2018/35.
How we check the data
Two readers. Each label's actives, Broad Spectrum claim and ingredient list are read from the package artwork filed with the FDA. The card says whether two readers agreed, one reader read it, or only the FDA filing was available.
Every week. Every label is re-checked against FDA DailyMed, and the card shows the date.
Every month. An independent audit re-reads 300 randomly picked labels against the package. The error rate and its 95% range are shown on the Check.
Corrections. Anyone, parent or brand, can report an error from a product card or at angela@arwhouse.com, with a photo of the package or a link. Two readers check it within 7 days; one report alone never changes a card. Every correction is listed.
What each ingredient does
Next to every ingredient we give its main job in a sunscreen. The source is the European Commission's CosIng ingredient register, which lists the functions each cosmetic ingredient is registered for. CosIng lists every function an ingredient may serve in any product, so for the most-used ingredients two people chose the main job separately and we kept it only when they agreed. For plant extracts we name what they are used as, not a benefit they promise.
Some labels print several ingredients run together; we split those and give each its job. When a name on the label can't be identified, a cut-off word or a typo we can't resolve, we say not yet checked instead of guessing.
What a label can't tell you
This check reads labels, so it can only report what a label says. Some things that matter for a child's sunscreen never appear on one:
Contamination. Benzene in some aerosol sprays, bacteria or mold in a bad batch. We show it when the FDA records a recall; we cannot test products ourselves.
Recalls we show. We show recalls by the maker or distributor of a product. A store pulling stock it stored badly (a store-level withdrawal) is not shown on product cards.
Particle size. US labels don't have to say whether zinc oxide or titanium dioxide is nano-sized.
Heavy metals. Mineral filters are mined; their purity is a manufacturing spec, not a label line.
Whether the SPF holds up. The SPF on the label is the brand's own test result. We report it as printed.
Amounts of inactive ingredients. Labels list them roughly from most to least, without amounts, and many brands list them alphabetically.
Changes to these rules
Card v4 · 2026-10-25 The result card was redesigned. Every item is now one fact with its official source, under 'Why this matters', with what points the other way and what is not known. Items are grouped as At a glance, About the UV filters, Label check, Check for your child (with Eczema, Psoriasis, Food allergy and Under 3 options) and Other ingredients some parents ask about. Colour follows the strength of the source: red only for an FDA recall, an FDA order or warning, or a combination pediatricians advise against. Sprays, chemical filters and 'possible SPF booster listed as inactive' are no longer shown in red. A green check is never shown where the ingredient list may be incomplete. Each card shows when it was last checked, and errors can be reported from it. An independent review of the check found warnings stronger than their sources, and a few green checks the label did not support. Every sentence on the card was then checked against its source by two further independent reviewers.
v3.13 · 2026-10-25 An ingredient the label itself calls an essential oil ('Cedarwood Essential Oils', 'fragrance (essential oils)') now counts as an essential oil even when the plant is not on our list; coconut stays a fixed oil whatever a label calls it. An independent review found a few labels naming essential oils that the check missed and showed 'No fragrance listed'.
v3.12 · 2026-10-24 Every label read once from its package artwork (5,388) was checked again by a second, independent reader. 4,555 matched; a match read with full confidence makes the label's evidence two agreeing reads (tier A: 6,229 labels, up from 2,087). Where the two readers differed, a third reader who was told neither answer settled Broad Spectrum and ingredient names: a fact two of three readers saw is used (Broad Spectrum now shown for 205 more labels; names printed on the package added to 81 lists, never taking one away). A filer's placeholder in the ingredient field ('Please kindly refer to artwork') is not shown as an ingredient; one product filed with hundreds of inactives is not shown a list. Methylparaben and Ethylparaben, or Ceteareth-10 and Ceteareth-20, are no longer taken for spelling variants of each other. Accuracy: the 2026-10-24 random audit found tier B (read once) as the largest group of labels without a second, independent check.
v3.11 · 2026-10-24 Korean and international cartons often print a full ingredient list beside the US Drug Facts panel. 466 such packages were read twice by independent readers; the names both reads agree on (433 labels, 13,980 entries) are added to the list shown, never taking a name away, so fragrance, parabens, cyclic silicones, triclosan and extra UV filters printed only in that list now give their warnings. A kit with a mist or spray gives the spray warning; chestnut is a tree nut; PEG derivatives of plant oils are not plant extracts; a record showing Broad Spectrum SPF 15+ drops a contradicting alert-based warning. Accuracy: the post-fix audits (2026-10-24) found Korean and international full lists as the largest remaining source of missing warnings.
v3.10 · 2026-10-24 505 products whose FDA filing names a contract manufacturer (Allure Labs, COSMAX, Prime Packaging, Fallien, Cross Brands and others) now show the brand and name printed on the package front, read from the filed artwork. Titanium dioxide or zinc oxide printed again as a colorant in the inactive list (CI 77891, 'may contain') is kept in the list. A misspelled single ingredient name ('Methyparaben', 'Proplyene Glycol') is shown spelled right. Accuracy: parents and experts look a product up by the brand on the package; the post-fix audit (2026-10-24) found these as its most common minor errors.
v3.9 · 2026-10-24 A second blind audit of 300 different labels (after v3.8) found smaller gaps, now fixed: 'Diethylhexyl 2' + '6-Naphthalate' rejoined as one name (its UV booster warning was lost); coneflower counts as a ragweed-family plant; a kit whose products print different SPFs shows the lowest; a package that says soy-free drops the soy warning for lecithin of unstated source; 'sr-' recombinant proteins (vegan collagen) are not animal-derived; label footnotes stuck to a name ('*Denotes') are removed; when a printed name does not itself give a warning, the warning cites the FDA filing name it comes from; an SPF under 15 read from the package or the name gives the below-SPF-15 warning. Accuracy: each change came from the post-fix stratified audit (2026-10-24). Same rules for every product.
v3.8 · 2026-10-24 A blind audit of 300 labels against their package artwork found rule gaps that each reached many labels, now fixed: BHT gave no warning (617 labels); avobenzone and ensulizole printed under their INCI names among the inactives gave no warning; Ext. Violet 2, trolamine, DEA-cetyl phosphate, emu oil, snail secretion, isopropyl alcohol, cyclomethicone 4, oligoglucosides, Optiphen and misspelled perfluoro- names now match; plain lecithin gives the soy warning with 'source not stated'; synthetic aroma chemicals give the fragrance warning even when an essential oil is also listed; diethylhexyl 2,6-naphthalate counts as a UV booster. A kit's list now keeps every product's ingredients. Where two reads of the package agree on the actives and the filing differs, the package's actives are shown. A strength misread (titanium dioxide 4% shown as 19.5% when the panel lists the names before the numbers) was fixed on 18 labels. 'Oil spray' on the package front marks a spray; a spray word only in label text on a package a person read as a lotion does not. 'No artificial fragrance' is no longer read as a named scent. A lactic/glycolic acid copolymer is not free glycolic acid. Accuracy: each change came from the final stratified audit (2026-10-24) or a sweep for the same gap across the database. Same rules for every product.
v3.7 · 2026-10-24 Every warning's explanation and source were checked against the primary source (EU regulation text, CFR, FDA orders, ACDS, AAP/AAD, peer-reviewed papers): 46 explanations reworded to say no more than the source supports, all 64 citations made specific, and 20 rules now say plainly that they are our judgment. Matching fixed where four random label audits found gaps: plant-family and food-allergen names the old dictionary missed (marigold, burdock, soy lecithin, almond oil, beeswax, coconut-derived ingredients), Polycrylene as a UV absorber, sunscreen + insect repellent products, and three false matches (Ligularia fischeri as fish, Poria cocos as coconut, gardenia as jasmine). Broad Spectrum is no longer read from the Drug Facts direction sentence. Accuracy: each change came from a source check or an audit of labels against their package artwork. Same rules for every product.
v3.6 · 2026-10-23 The check now reads the ingredient list printed on the label, not names that appear only in the FDA filing. A filing name still counts when it is a printed ingredient under another name or says what it comes from (soy or egg lecithin, fish collagen). Strengths come from the printed Drug Facts; a strength the filing gives per volume is not converted. One filing that covers several products says so. Also: methyldibromo glutaronitrile (banned in EU cosmetics) is flagged; an SPF under 15 gets the not-broad-spectrum flag; propylene glycol esters are not propylene glycol; seed oils are not essential oils; pain-relief creams are no longer listed as sunscreens. A check of 736 labels against their printed cartons found warnings resting on names only the FDA filing had (often another scent or an older formula), strengths converted from the filing's units (13.2% shown for a printed 12%), and kits whose products were merged. Each fix is the same rule for every brand.
v3.5 · 2026-10-22 Three label checks added to 'Act on it': a sunscreen combined with an insect repellent (AAP), ingredients the EU restricts for children under 3 (salicylic acid, boric acid and borates), and fully fluorinated PFAS ingredients (state cosmetic bans since 2025). Each label's full text is now read for its Broad Spectrum claim and for the FDA Skin Cancer/Skin Aging Alert, which marks a sunscreen that is not broad spectrum or is below SPF 15. The EU fragrance-allergen check now covers the full list as extended in 2023 (Regulation (EU) 2023/1545), such as camphor, menthol, vanillin and citrus peel oils; when a label has only these and no fragrance, the summary says 'Contains an EU-listed fragrance allergen'. A review of what a baby-sunscreen check should catch found these on real labels and not yet covered.
v3.4 · 2026-10-22 Each group now has one written test. 'Check if your child reacts' is limited to three named lists (ACDS Allergen of the Year, EU labelled fragrance allergens, US major food allergens), so alkyl glucosides, sulfites and isobornyl acrylate are added; ragweed-family plants, bee-derived ingredients, oat and drying alcohol move to 'Also in it'. Propyl/butylparaben and phototoxic citrus move to 'Act on it' (EU restrictions). Synthetic beeswax no longer counts as bee-derived; an essential oil must be an oil. Ingredient jobs now come from the EU CosIng register, reviewed twice. So that what we show first follows a test anyone can check, the same for every brand.
v3.3 · 2026-10-22 'Contains synthetic polymer microparticles' is now 'Contains a synthetic polymer powder (for texture)'. 'Microparticles' is a term defined in the EU microplastics restriction (Regulation (EU) 2023/2055). Whether that restriction applies is a product-by-product legal judgement a label cannot settle, so the check now states the ingredient fact only. Same rule for every product; the same ingredients are matched as before.
Sources
FDA DailyMed, Structured Product Labeling for every OTC sunscreen
European Commission CosIng ingredient register
American Contact Dermatitis Society, Allergen of the Year
EU Cosmetics Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Annexes II, III and V, and Regulation (EU) 2023/1545
US major food allergens: FALCPA, FASTER Act 2021, FDA food allergen guidance (January 2025)
FDA recall enforcement reports
Every source cited above, linked next to its sentence