ARW House Evidence

Library / Findings

Finding · DailyMed labels × EU law

Preservatives banned in EU cosmetics, on US baby sunscreen labels

14of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: lists isobutylparaben or methylisothiazolinone.

14 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database list a preservative that the EU no longer allows in products like them: isobutylparaben in 9, banned from all EU cosmetics, and methylisothiazolinone in 5, banned from EU leave-on cosmetics.

Not a violation in the US: neither preservative is banned in US sunscreens. In the EU a sunscreen is a cosmetic, so EU cosmetics law applies to it. The finding compares label records with EU law; it is not about any brand.

DailyMed lists drug labels submitted to the FDA, including labels for products made in US facilities for other markets. A listing is not proof that a product is on US shelves today.

Two preservatives

What the EU decided, and how many labels list each

IngredientFormulasEU rule
isobutylparaben9Banned from all cosmetics in the EU. Products containing it could no longer be made available on the EU market from July 30, 2015. EU law
methylisothiazolinone5Banned from leave-on cosmetics in the EU. Leave-on products containing it could no longer be made available on the EU market from February 12, 2017. EU law

Every formula

The 14 labels

Baby or kids labelListsLabel version dateWhere it is listed
BANANA BOAT (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE) SPRAY [EDGEWELL PERSONAL CARE BRANDS, LLC]isobutylparaben2025-11-06FDA filing, printed label
BANANA BOAT KIDS TEAR FREE CONTINUOUS SPF 50 (AVOBENZONE AND HOMOSALATE AND OCTINOXATE AND OCTISALATE AND OCTOCRYLENE) SPRAY [ACCRA-PAC, INC.]isobutylparaben2010-03-18FDA filing, printed label
BANANA BOAT ULTRAMIST BABY TEAR FREE CONTINUOUS SPF 50 (AVOBENZONE AND HOMOSALATE AND OCTINOXATE AND OCTISALATE AND OCTOCRYLENE) SPRAY [ACCRA-PAC, INC.]isobutylparaben2010-03-18FDA filing, printed label
FRUIT OF THE EARTH BLOCK UP KIDS SPF 50 MOISTURIZING SUNSCREEN (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTINOXATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, OXYBENZONE) LOTION [FRUIT OF THE EARTH, INC.]isobutylparaben2017-05-23FDA filing, printed label
KROGER KIDS TEAR FREE SPF50 (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE) SPRAY [KROGER COMPANY]isobutylparaben2016-01-05FDA filing, printed label
MEIJER BABY TEAR FREE SPF 50 CS (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE) SPRAY [MEIJER DISTRIBUTION, INC.]isobutylparaben2016-03-11FDA filing, printed label
NO-AD KIDS 50 SUNSCREEN (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OXYBENZONE) LOTION [SUN & SKIN CARE RESEARCH, LLC]isobutylparaben2012-05-17FDA filing, printed label
ULTRASOL KIDS (AVOBENZONE, OCTINOXATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, OXYBENZONE) AEROSOL, FOAM [FISCHER PHARMACEUTICALS LTD.]isobutylparaben2010-05-06printed label
ULTRASOLSUNSCREEN KIDS SUNSCREEN MOUSSE (AVOBENZONE, OCTINOXATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, OXYBENZONE) AEROSOL, FOAM [FISCHER PHARMACEUTICALS LTD.]isobutylparaben2010-03-25printed label
AUSTRALIAN GOLD BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 30 (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, AND OXYBENZONE) LOTION [PRIME ENTERPRISES, INC.]methylisothiazolinone2020-01-17FDA filing, printed label
DEFENSE ZONE KIDS BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50 SUNSCREEN (HOMOSALATE, OCTINOXATE, OCTISALATE, TITANIUM DIOXIDE) LOTION [PRIME ENTERPRISES INC.]methylisothiazolinone2020-01-17FDA filing, printed label
SOLMATE BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50 (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE AND OXYBENZONE) SPRAY [PRIME PACKAGING, INC.]methylisothiazolinone2020-01-17FDA filing, printed label
SUNTONE KIDS BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50 SUNSCREEN (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, AND OXYBENZONE) LOTION [PRIME ENTERPRISES INC.]methylisothiazolinone2020-01-17FDA filing, printed label
TENDER MOMENTS BABY SUNSCREEN BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50 JAFRA (AVOBENZONE, HOMOSALATE, OCTISALATE, OCTOCRYLENE, OXYBENZONE) LIQUID [JAFRA COSMETICS INTERNATIONAL]methylisothiazolinone2020-06-22FDA filing, printed label

Each name links to its FDA DailyMed record. The date is that of the label version currently in DailyMed; an old label date does not show whether the product is still sold.

Not banned, but labeled in the EU

Formaldehyde-releasing preservatives

7 of the 446 formulas list diazolidinyl urea, a preservative that releases formaldehyde. SAG-CS It is not banned in the EU and is not counted above. Since Regulation (EU) 2022/1181, EU products that release more than 0.001% formaldehyde must carry the warning “releases formaldehyde”. EU 2022/1181 US labels do not state how much formaldehyde is released, so the 0.001% level cannot be checked from them.

Searched: diazolidinyl urea, imidazolidinyl urea, DMDM hydantoin, quaternium-15, bronopol, sodium hydroxymethylglycinate. Only the ingredients found are named above.

What this means

In the EU, a sunscreen is a cosmetic, so EU cosmetics law decides which preservatives it may contain. EU law

The EU has banned isobutylparaben from all cosmetics and methylisothiazolinone from leave-on cosmetics, which include sunscreens. US rules for sunscreen inactive ingredients have no such ban. This finding counts baby and kids labels in DailyMed that list either one.

How we counted

Population: unique formulations of sunscreen labels that say baby or kids in the product name or on the front panel, plus the sunscreens of baby-care brands (Tubby Todd, Pipette, Mustela, Babo Botanicals, Babyganics, California Baby, Thinkbaby, Sqween, Putto; tinted and lip products excluded) (FDA DailyMed; selected by rule from the label, with edge cases decided by hand and every decision recorded with its reason; a claim such as 'suitable for children' alone does not count; labels that name a foreign distributor or importer and labels that do not meet US sunscreen limits as listed left out; a listing that bundles several products is split into its products). That is 446 unique formulations, of which 245 use only mineral actives (zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide). DailyMed snapshot 2026-11-16.

Every include and exclude decision, with its reason · The counting script · Label errors we corrected

Questions

Are these products illegal?

Not a violation in the US: neither preservative is banned in US sunscreens. In the EU a sunscreen is a cosmetic, so EU cosmetics law applies to it. The finding compares label records with EU law; it is not about any brand.

What exactly did the EU ban?

Isobutylparaben was added to the list of substances banned in cosmetics by Commission Regulation (EU) No 358/2014; products containing it could no longer be made available on the EU market from July 30, 2015. Methylisothiazolinone was limited to rinse-off products by Commission Regulation (EU) 2016/1198, so leave-on products containing it could no longer be made available from February 12, 2017.

Are other parabens banned too?

This finding counts only isobutylparaben among the parabens. The same EU regulation also banned isopropylparaben, phenylparaben, benzylparaben and pentylparaben; none of the baby and kids labels lists them. Methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben and butylparaben remain allowed in the EU within limits.

How were these products selected?

Population: unique formulations of sunscreen labels that say baby or kids in the product name or on the front panel, plus the sunscreens of baby-care brands (Tubby Todd, Pipette, Mustela, Babo Botanicals, Babyganics, California Baby, Thinkbaby, Sqween, Putto; tinted and lip products excluded) (FDA DailyMed; selected by rule from the label, with edge cases decided by hand and every decision recorded with its reason; a claim such as 'suitable for children' alone does not count; labels that name a foreign distributor or importer and labels that do not meet US sunscreen limits as listed left out; a listing that bundles several products is split into its products). That is 446 unique formulations, of which 245 use only mineral actives (zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide).