ARW House Evidence

Findings

What the labels show, counted.

Each finding is a count of baby and kids sunscreen labels in the FDA's DailyMed database, checked against the rules that apply to them. Every number links to its data and every rule to its source.

201of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: contains at least one of the 12 ingredients.

Finding · DailyMed labels × FDA review

201 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database contain at least one of the 12 active ingredients the FDA has proposed need more safety data. 153 of them contain four or more.

Read the finding →
151of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: homosalate above 7.34%.

Finding · DailyMed labels × EU law

151 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database contain homosalate above 7.34%, the highest level the EU allows. The EU allows it only in face products other than propellant sprays; the US allows up to 15% in any sunscreen.

Read the finding →
14of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: lists isobutylparaben or methylisothiazolinone.

Finding · DailyMed labels × EU law

14 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database list a preservative that the EU no longer allows in products like them: isobutylparaben in 9, banned from all EU cosmetics, and methylisothiazolinone in 5, banned from EU leave-on cosmetics.

Read the finding →
90of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: contains oxybenzone or octinoxate.

Finding · DailyMed labels × Hawaii law

90 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database contain oxybenzone or octinoxate. Since January 1, 2021, Hawaii law has made it unlawful to sell, offer for sale or distribute for sale in the state a sunscreen containing either one without a prescription.

Read the finding →
99of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: same ingredients as a label that does not say baby or kids.

Finding · DailyMed labels

99 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database list the same ingredients in their Drug Facts as a sunscreen whose label does not say baby or kids: the same active ingredients at the same percentages and the same inactive ingredients in the same order. In at least 84 cases both labels name the same labeler.

Read the finding →
6of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: says mineral on the front and also lists an organic (chemical) UV filter.

Finding · DailyMed labels, front panel × Drug Facts

6 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database say “mineral” on the front of the package, such as “mineral-based” or “mineral enriched”, but their active ingredients also include organic UV filters, often called chemical filters, such as homosalate, octocrylene, octinoxate or octisalate. To know whether a sunscreen is mineral only, read the Active ingredients in the Drug Facts box: only zinc oxide and titanium dioxide are mineral filters.

Read the finding →
159of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: contains at least one of the six booster ingredients.

Finding · DailyMed labels × manufacturer data

159 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database contain a synthetic ingredient that its manufacturer sells to boost SPF or stabilize UV filters, or that the EU regulates as a UV filter, listed under Inactive ingredients. That includes 93 of the 245 mineral formulas, whose only active ingredients are zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide.

Read the finding →
138of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: lists fragrance or parfum.

Finding · DailyMed labels × AAD guidance

138 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database list fragrance (or parfum) as an ingredient. For children with eczema, the American Academy of Dermatology advises a sunscreen that is fragrance-free.

Read the finding →
30of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: says hypoallergenic and lists fragrance.

Finding · DailyMed labels × FDA and AAD

30 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database say “hypoallergenic” on the label and also list fragrance as an ingredient. The FDA says there is no federal standard or definition for the term “hypoallergenic”, and for children with eczema the American Academy of Dermatology advises a fragrance-free sunscreen.

Read the finding →
113of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: a spray.

Finding · DailyMed labels × AAP guidance

113 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database are sprays, from 48 labelers. To avoid inhalation, the American Academy of Pediatrics suggests lotions, or, if a spray is used, spraying it onto the hands and then applying it to the child.

Read the finding →
45of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: lists at least one paraben.

Finding · DailyMed labels × EU law

45 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database list at least one paraben preservative: propylparaben in 44, methylparaben in 45, butylparaben in 18, ethylparaben in 18 and isobutylparaben in 9.

Read the finding →