ARW House Evidence

Library / Findings

Finding · DailyMed labels × FDA review

Nearly half of baby and kids sunscreen formulas in DailyMed use an ingredient the FDA has proposed needs more safety data

201of 446

Each door is one baby or kids formula. Filled: contains at least one of the 12 ingredients.

201 of the 446 baby and kids sunscreen formulas listed in the FDA's DailyMed label database contain at least one of the 12 active ingredients the FDA has proposed need more safety data. 153 of them contain four or more.

Legal today: all 12 ingredients are permitted under the current US sunscreen monograph. The FDA has proposed that they need more data before they can be recognized as safe and effective. The finding is about what labels contain, not about any brand.

DailyMed lists drug labels submitted to the FDA, including labels for products made in US facilities for other markets. A listing is not proof that a product is on US shelves today.

Which of the 12

How many of the 446 formulas list each one

Cinoxate, Dioxybenzone, Padimate O, Sulisobenzone: none of the 446. One formula can contain several; 153 contain four or more.

What this means

The FDA has proposed that 12 sunscreen active ingredients are not GRASE (generally recognized as safe and effective) because the public record does not contain sufficient data to support a positive determination, and it is asking for safety data on them. FDA

For zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, the FDA says its review of publicly available evidence found sufficient safety data. FDA

All 12 remain permitted under the current US monograph, at the limits shown on each ingredient page.

How we counted

Population: unique formulations of sunscreen labels that say baby or kids in the product name or on the front panel, plus the sunscreens of baby-care brands (Tubby Todd, Pipette, Mustela, Babo Botanicals, Babyganics, California Baby, Thinkbaby, Sqween, Putto; tinted and lip products excluded) (FDA DailyMed; selected by rule from the label, with edge cases decided by hand and every decision recorded with its reason; a claim such as 'suitable for children' alone does not count; labels that name a foreign distributor or importer and labels that do not meet US sunscreen limits as listed left out; a listing that bundles several products is split into its products). That is 446 unique formulations, of which 245 use only mineral actives (zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide). DailyMed snapshot 2026-11-16.

Every include and exclude decision, with its reason · The counting script · Label errors we corrected

Questions

Does this mean these sunscreens are unsafe?

This finding makes no safety judgment. The FDA has proposed that these 12 ingredients need more data before they can be recognized as safe and effective, and all 12 remain permitted under the current US monograph.

Which sunscreen ingredients does the FDA say have sufficient safety data?

Zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. The FDA says its review of publicly available evidence found sufficient safety data on both.

How were these products selected?

Population: unique formulations of sunscreen labels that say baby or kids in the product name or on the front panel, plus the sunscreens of baby-care brands (Tubby Todd, Pipette, Mustela, Babo Botanicals, Babyganics, California Baby, Thinkbaby, Sqween, Putto; tinted and lip products excluded) (FDA DailyMed; selected by rule from the label, with edge cases decided by hand and every decision recorded with its reason; a claim such as 'suitable for children' alone does not count; labels that name a foreign distributor or importer and labels that do not meet US sunscreen limits as listed left out; a listing that bundles several products is split into its products). That is 446 unique formulations, of which 245 use only mineral actives (zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide).